Custom Baked Goods

At the Frosty Frog Creamery & Café, we strive to meet your needs. We bake just about ALL of our mouth-watering cakes, cookies, brownies and goodies right in the store using natural ingredients, creating an unequaled taste temptation. Some of our desserts are delivered to us from fine bakeries and other quality sources in the area.

We offer a standard list of baked offerings, but can bake just about anything you can think of! We do of course have our limitations, and will tell you what they are UP FRONT so that there are no disappointments.

We Do Custom Baking

Do you need something baked for that special occasion, party or just dinner with the family? Don’t have either the time, talent or desire to do the baking yourself? Avoid the ‘cardboard-tasting’ cakes from the mega-markets with a custom-baked item from the Frosty Frog Creamery & Café.

Custom baking orders must be placed three days in advance. Contact us to place your order and let us take care of the food details for your next event or special gathering. For pricing and scheduling on all custom-baked items, please contact us or call 770-704-9340.

See photos of some of the cakes we have created.\

Our desserts are all homemade and fresh- just like your mom used to make.Chocolate Chip Cookies

Custom cakes in many flavors:

  • Italian Cream
  • Banana Chocolate Chip w/ Chocolate Icing
  • Red Velvet
  • German Chocolate
  • Vanilla Cake w/ Old Fashioned Caramel Icing
  • Coconut
  • Vanilla Cake w/ Peanut Butter Icing
  • Yellow Cake w/ Chocolate Icing
  • Chocolate Cake w/ 7 Minute or Chocolate Icing
  • Hummingbird Cake w/ Cream Cheese Icing
  • Tiramisu Toffee Torte
  • Vanilla cake w/ P’nut Butter Fluff Filling w/ Chocolate Icing
  • Mocha Swirl
  • The Strawberry Cake
  • Cupcakes
Custom Cakes in All Flavors Mickey Mouse Custom Cake Strawberry Cake Custom Cakes - Traditional or Ice Cream Donald Duck Cake in traditional cake or ice cream Wedding Cake

  • Pumpkin Spice w/ Brown Butter Glaze
  • Whipping Cream w/ Vanilla Glaze
  • Lemon w/ Lemon Glaze
  • Coconut w/ Coconut Glaze
  • Sweet Potato w/ Citrus Glaze
  • Banana w/ Caramel Glaze
  • Six Flavor w/ Six Flavor Glaze
  • Chocolate w/ Fudge Glaze
  • White Chocolate w/ White Chocolate Glaze

Homemade pies and cheese cakes in a different flavors. Seasonal pies for Fall like pumpkin and Apple.

  • Pecan
  • Brownie PecanPumpkin Pie
  • Lemon Coconut or Lemon Pecan
  • Pumpkin
  • Chocolate Chip/Pecan
  • Mocha Fudge
  • Mocha Almond
  • Lemon MeringueCheese Cakes and Pies
  • Coconut Cream
  • Chocolate Cream
  • Banana Cream
  • Apple Pie (Seasonal-only available October and November)
Call Now ButtonCall In Your Order